
The city’s new Downtown zoning plan has yet another draft, this time with a new district along Washington Street that will allow buildings of up to 500 feet tall, and Downtown residents are not happy.
At a virtual public meeting last Wednesday, they berated Boston Planning Department (BPD) officials over the new PLAN: Downtown proposal, which they said all but scrapped six years of work by a city selected community and expert advisory board.
“When we were talking about PLAN:
Downtown,
and we’ve been talking about it for six years, we were talking about
155 feet,” Martha McNamara, a preservationist who served on the advisory
board, said in the meeting.
“What
we now have is a strip of 500 feet that runs through the center of this
historic and vibrant neighborhood. What this amendment tells me is that
you have wasted my time.”
PLAN:
Downtown originated in 2018 as a way to revitalize a neighborhood that
had not been zoned since 1989. The new plan was intended to simplify the
area to make it easier for developers, while preserving important
historic landmarks and creating an inviting mixed-use district for
residents.
Under the
latest iteration of the zoning plan, released by Mayor Michelle Wu’s
office on January 8, Downtown will have a new “SKY-R” district, which
encompasses Washington and Stewart Streets. In this district, buildings
are limited to a height of 155 feet, unless over 60 percent of building
use is residential, in which case the maximum height is 500 feet.
Housing was the Planning Department’s biggest selling point in the
meeting.
“Key
corridors like Washington Street can really support critical housing
growth for the city,” senior planner Andrew Nahmias said in the meeting.
“Overall, this [zone] is meant to reinforce the spine of Washington
Street, while recognizing the sensitivity of some of the historic fabric
there.”
Residents
have until February 4 to comment on the draft. In the virtual meeting on
January 15, however, they came out in full force. Attendance in the
Zoom meeting hovered around 230 people, and the meeting lasted a full
two hours. The most common concern was timing.
“With
all due respect, this plan was dropped in our laps less than a week
ago,” said Ryan St Marie, the manager of a luxury residential building
that would be in the new SKY-R district. “This short time period is a
slap in the face. I guarantee there would be 500 people on this call if
you gave us proper notice. The fact that you’re giving us three weeks to
respond, not appropriate.”
The
other overwhelming concern among residents was that the new draft
looked nothing like the previous iteration of the plan, issued last
April. Rishi Shukla, the head of the Downtown Boston Residents’
Association who served on the advisory board, said that the previous
plan had supported about 80 percent of what the board had suggested, but
that the new plan looked nothing like it.
“The
increase of height along the entirety of Washington Street was
literally never contemplated because it was such a ridiculous notion,
even back then,” Shukla said in a phone call. “The idea that we’re
talking about that now as a solution is just. It’s a head scratcher.”
Kairos
Shen, the head of the BPD since September, said he thought the current
draft was a good compromise between the competing needs of developers
and residents. Shen ran the planning department before the Walsh
administration and was responsible for developing much of the Seaport.
“There’s
been a lot of concern about some of the changes, and whether you will
have enough time to actually review them,” Shen said at the end of the
meeting. “So I’ve registered them. I think me being here tonight is
representative of how serious we are taking the issues that have been
raised.”
Two days
after the meeting, the Planning Department announced it would hold
another “office hours” meeting the next Wednesday for residents to voice
more concerns.
“Within
City Hall, my understanding from sources is this set off a bit of a
firestorm internally,” Shukla said in a phone call. “Nobody was
expecting the participation that they saw.”